BeaconsvsWinly

The Beacons Smart Reply alternative for selling in DMs

Beacons is a creator platform with link in bio, a store, email and a media kit, and its Smart Reply sends an Instagram DM when someone comments a keyword. Winly is for the sale after that: a pipeline for Instagram and Facebook DMs, plus an MCP server so your AI agent can read your threads and draft replies. If you want link DMs from comments next to your store and email list, Beacons is the simpler pick.

  • Free plan, no card
  • 52 MCP tools
  • Instagram and Facebook

Works with the AI agent you already use

Smart Reply sends the link. Then the chat is yours

In Beacons, you pick one post or all posts, add a keyword, and write a DM with up to three link buttons. Smart Reply can ask for an email first, reply to the comment in public, and send a reminder if the link isn't opened. Beacons lists no MCP server, AI replies in DMs or sales pipeline. Winly picks up when a person writes back, with stages, owners and reports, and your AI agent can read the chat and draft replies.

Winly: when a lead replies, your AI agent reads the thread, drafts the answer and tracks the sale.

“Every commenter gets your message with up to three link buttons, automatically.”
Beacons Smart Reply page, read Nov 20, 2026

Selling in DMs vs a creator platform with auto-DMs

Winly
  • Built for sales chats in Instagram and Facebook DMs
  • Pipeline stages, tags, notes and an owner for each lead
  • Reports on reply speed, quiet leads and drop-off
  • 52 MCP tools for Claude, ChatGPT and other AI agents
  • Comment-to-DM and new-DM templates from your AI agent
  • Free plan: $0, 300 credits a month, 1 Instagram account and 1 Facebook Page, no card
Beacons
  • A creator platform: link in bio, store, email and media kit
  • Smart Reply DMs a link when people comment a keyword
  • Unlimited keyword DMs and follow-ups on every plan, Free included
  • Sends, clicks and click rate for each automation
  • No MCP server or pipeline listed
  • Free plan at $0. Paid plans from $10 a month, billed monthly

Winly vs Beacons

FeatureWinlyBeacons
Built forSelling in DMsCreators: link in bio, store, email and media kit
Comment to DMYesYes, Smart Reply
MCP server for your DMsYes, 52 toolsNone listed
AI that replies in DMsYour AI agent, or Autopilot on sales team plansNot listed
Pipeline stages and ownersYesNot listed. Audience contacts and groups
ReportsReply speed, quiet leads, drop-offSends, clicks and click rate for each automation
Free plan$0, 300 credits a month, 1 Instagram account and 1 Facebook Page, no card$0 with Smart Reply, a store and 50 email sends a month. 9% seller fee
Paid plansOn the pricing pageCreator $10, Creator Plus $30, Creator Max $100 a month, billed monthly
ChannelsInstagram, Facebook. Team plans add SMS, email and web chatInstagram for Smart Reply, plus email marketing
Sell products and coursesNoYes, with checkout

Why sellers pick Winly

  • Built for the sale

    Stages, tags, notes and an owner for every lead who writes back.

  • Reports on the sale

    Reply speed, quiet leads, drop-off and your best messages.

  • Works in your AI agent

    Ask your AI agent who's waiting on a reply, and have it draft the answer. Beacons lists no MCP server.

  • Comment to DM, too

    On any plan, Free included, your AI agent can set up a comment-to-DM workflow and a reply for new DMs.

  • Instagram and Facebook

    Work Instagram DMs and Facebook Page messages in one place. Smart Reply covers Instagram.

  • Works inside Meta's reply window

    Your AI agent's DMs go only to people who messaged, commented or reacted first. Text can go up to 7 days after their last message, media up to 24 hours.

What Beacons does well

Credit where it's due.

  • Smart Reply on the free plan

    Keyword DMs and follow-ups are unlimited on every plan, Free included.

  • One place for creators

    Link in bio, store, email, media kit and Smart Reply in one login.

  • Grows your email list

    Smart Reply can ask for an email before it sends the link, and adds the contact to your Beacons audience.

Winly or Beacons

Choose Winly if you:
  • Sell in your DMs and need to track each lead
  • Want your AI agent to read and answer threads
  • Have setters or a team working one pipeline
  • Sell on Facebook as well as Instagram
  • Want reports on reply speed and drop-off
Stay with Beacons if you:
  • Want link in bio, a store and email in one place
  • Mostly want to send links from comments
  • Sell digital products, courses or memberships
  • Want a media kit for brand deals

Already on Beacons?

Keep your link in bio and store. Create a free Winly account, connect Instagram or Facebook, and add Winly to your AI agent. See which one helps you close more of your DMs.

Frequently asked questions

Is Beacons Smart Reply free?

Yes. Smart Reply is on Beacons' Free plan, and keyword DMs and follow-ups are unlimited on every plan. Free and Creator take a 9% seller fee on store sales.

What does Beacons cost?

Free is $0. Creator is $10 a month, Creator Plus $30 and Creator Max $100, billed monthly, as of Nov 20, 2026. Yearly billing costs less. Winly's Free plan is $0 with 300 credits a month, 1 Instagram account and 1 Facebook Page, no card. Paid plans are on the pricing page.

Does Beacons have an MCP server?

None is listed, as of Nov 20, 2026. Beacons' file for AI agents (llms.txt) and its pricing page name no MCP server. With Winly, Claude, ChatGPT and other AI agents can read your DMs and draft replies through Winly's MCP server.

Does Smart Reply work on Facebook or TikTok?

Beacons says Smart Reply works with Instagram and doesn't automate TikTok comments yet. Facebook is not listed. Winly works with Instagram and Facebook DMs.

Can Winly send a link when someone comments?

Yes. Your AI agent can set up a comment-to-DM workflow on any plan, Free included. Sales team plans add a canvas workflow builder with triggers, actions, delays and branches.

Who can my AI agent message with Winly?

Only people who messaged, commented or reacted first. It can send text up to 7 days after their last message, and media up to 24 hours after.

Is Winly free?

Yes. The Free plan is $0 with 300 credits a month, 1 Instagram account and 1 Facebook Page. You don't need a card.

Which AI agents work with Winly?

Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, Grok and other AI agents that can add a remote MCP server.

Facts about Beacons come from its public site, read on Nov 20, 2026. See something wrong? Email hello@getwinly.ai.

More comparisons

See all comparisons

BeaconsvsWinly

Turn replies into sales

Free to start. No card. Works with Claude, ChatGPT and other AI agents that can add a remote MCP server.

  • No card needed
  • Meta's official sign-in
  • Cancel any time
Free plan. No card.Get Started for Free